Stelen’s private life reflects the low-profile discipline instilled by his parents. In November 2021, Stelen married his longtime partner, Haley Covel, in a private ceremony held in Las Vegas, Nevada. The event drew close friends and immediate family, keeping tabloid coverage to a minimum.
Haley Covel works alongside Stelen within their community, maintaining an understated public footprint. While celebrity children frequently use social media followings to pursue lifestyle influencer deals, Stelen and Haley use their platforms sparingly, sharing occasional family photos, wedding anniversaries, and updates from Sooner football games.
During the tribute events organized across 2024 and 2025, including the star-studded concert special at Bridgestone Arena and Toby Keith’s posthumous induction into the Country Music Hall of Fame, Stelen supported his mother and sisters publicly. When he addressed his father’s passing online, his words cut through the noise: "You are the strongest man I have ever known. A fighter. You are my hero and I am so lucky to have had you."